Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label No True Scotsman

Is Charlie Kirk a Martyr? A Philosophical and Biblical Look at the Truth of the Matter

Many words have been spoken over whether or not Charlie Kirk is a Christian martyr. It has seemed to me from the beginning that Kirk was a Christian martyr, and I knew that people would be divided on the subject. So, after several of my own discussions, nine days after Charlie Kirk’s assassination, I crafted a philosophical argument. The Truth of the Matter, Philosophically Speaking   1. If Charlie Kirk’s values were built on the foundation of Christ (P), then the truths that he taught from these values were the reason he was murdered (Q). 2. If the truths he taught from these values were the reason he was murdered (Q), then Charlie kirk is a martyr (R). 3. Charlie Kirk’s values were built on the foundation of Christ (P). 4. If Charlie Kirk’s values were built on the foundation of Christ (P), then Charlie Kirk is a martyr (R). 5. Charlie Kirk is a Christian Martyr (R).   (Hypothetical syllogism 1,2) (Modus ponens 3,4)   For a frame of reference, see these two passages bel...